Outline the ontological argument for the existence of god and consider the view that, while it may strengthen a believers faith, it has no value for the nonbeliever. The ontological argument is widely thought to have been first clearly articulated by st. Clean without writing dare i say like new except it is almost 50 years old. The ontological argument st anselm and descartes both famously presented an ontological argument for the existence of god. More specifically, ontological arguments tend to start with an a priori theory about the organization of the universe. The ontological argument is certainly interesting and has long intrigued thinkers, yet as a consistent argument proving its case, it falls flat. The one fatal flaw in anselms argument 439 gods existence, and another under which it is validand indeed soundbut fails to prove the existence of god. Anselms ontological argument for the existence of god anselms argument is an a priori argument. I have to say, i think several of the objections presented against the ontological argument basically miss the mark. William forgie and others published the caterus objection. He ontological argument for the existence of god has.
The ontological argument uses existence as a predicate, that is, as a characteristic of god that can be found and added to our understanding of god. In an analytic proposition, the predicate concept is contained in its subject concept. I argue that only the last of these claims, originally voiced by kant, is both plausible and relevant to the ontological argument. Anselms ontological argument objection against existence.
Objections to the ontological argument existence of god. Alvin plantinga from god, freedom, and evil 1 the third theistic argument i wish to discuss is the famous ontological argument first formulated by anselm of canterbury in the eleventh century. Previous index next kant s objection to the ontological argument kant s background to the ontological argument immanuel kant 17241804 does not seem to show familiarity with anselms version of the ontological argument, and it appears that he is responding to its less impressive forms found in the writings of rene descartes 15961650 and christian wolff 16791754. Get an ad free experience with special benefits, and directly support reddit. Plantinga wisely refrains from discussing this obvious objection.
Within aquinas empiricism, we cannot reason or infer the existence of god from a studying of the definition of god. The ontological argument is an argument for gods existence based entirely on reason. The ontological argument from the proslogion, by anselm, bishop of canterbury c. How does the ontological argument support the existence of. Their versions of the argument are slightly different, but. For an underlying assumption of the truth of premise 2 is that existence is a predicate like blue, round and groovy are. Subscribe to jaysanalysis in the purchase membership section to access the archives of videos and interviews and lectures or purchase my books in the shop. Ontological arguments stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Anselm to contemporary philosophers alvin plantinga, richard taylor on. Pdf it is often said that the ontological argument fails because it.
Anselm developed a controversial a priori argument for the exis tence of god. This is an a prioriargument for the existence of god. I suppose most philosophers have been inclined to reject the argument, although it has an illustrious line. The relevance of kants objection to anselms ontological argument. It is the argument that, if one understands what is meant by the word god and follows it out to the logical conclusion, it is impossible for such a being not to exist. However, in our opinion, much of this literature ignores or misrepresents the elegant simplicity of the original argument. The word ontological comes from ontology, the study of ology of what exists or being ont.
Discussion anselms ontological argument objection against existence of god self. Descartes ontological argument i in the fifth meditation, descartes is considering various mathematical and conceptual truths i for instance, we know simply by analyzing the concept \triangle that the interior angles of a triangle equal two right angles i likewise, we know by the concept \mountain that wherever there is a mountain there is a valley. The ontological argument itself therefore an a priori argumen. What was particularly intetesting was seeing alvin plantingas rebuttal of the argument he would later come to support, although only after tweaking it which i think has really transormed it and is the most convincing form of it that ive ever read. In other words, ontological arguments are arguments from what are typically alleged to be none but analytic, a priori and necessary premises to the. Critique my response to kants objection to the ontological argument. An ontological argument is a philosophical argument for the existence of god that uses ontology. He uses a direct application of anslems argument you must think of the greatest or most perfect island because the greatest most perfect island must exist, as well as having all those desirable property, since we can conceive of the most perfect island, it must exist. Kant thought that because the ontological argument rests on the judgement that a god that exists is greater than a god that does not, it rests on a confusion.
Immanuel kant put forward an influential criticism of the ontological argument in his. I shall take it for granted that the connection between what i call ontological arguments and traditional presenta tions of the ontological argument there is, of course, no one argument that can be called the ontological argument is plain. The word ontology is a greek word relating to the concept of being. Ontological argument criticisms introduction to philosophy. Kants objection to the ontological argument andrew m. Aquinas, 1225 1274 built one objection to the ontological argument on epistemological grounds. Anselms ontological argument for the existence of god. Anselms text anselms ontological argument is presented in his proslogion, starting with chapter ii, though where. The ontological argument in pvs 1 introduction computer science. Kants objection to the ontological argument ethos education. How is this an objection to the ontological argument.
Three versions of the ontological argument andrew m. This paper argues that kants most famous objection to the ontological argument that existence is not a real predicate is not, in fact, his most effective objection. Some of this article goes well beyond the information necessary. The most influential criticism of the ontological argument is that of immanuel kant.
The one fatal flaw in anselms argument peter millican. This argument for the existence of god has fascinated philosophers ever since anselm first stated it. But it is not obvious how this slogan is supposed to relate to the. Although this is undoubtably leibnizs primary reason for attempting to prove gods possibility, examina. The ontological argument for gods existence is a particular kind of philosophical argument which christian theologians have developed for centuries as a way of showing why it is rational to believe in gods existence. In contrast, the ontological arguments are conceptual in roughly the following sense. The journal of philosophy kants objection to the ontological argument he ontological argument for the existence of god has 1fascinated and puzzled philosophers ever since it was first formulated by st.
Historically, however, the term is inextricably associated with the famous argument presented in anselms proslogion chapter ii, and with. Anselm of canterbury, who defined god as the greatest conceivable being. It is often said that the ontological argument fails because it wrongly treats existence as a firstlevel property or predicate. The ontological argument says that existence is a characteristic of perfection. The ontological argument responses and objections by. Ontological argument for the gods existence internet. As the objection is sometimes put, anselm simply defines things into. Anselms reasoning was that, if a being existed only in the mind but not in reality, then a greater being was conceivable a being which exists both in the mind and in reality. The relevance of kants objection to anselms ontological argument chris heathwood department of philosophy, university of colorado at boulder, 232 ucb, boulder, co 803090232 email. Objections to the conceptual ontological argument youtube.
Ontological arguments are arguments, for the conclusion that god exists, from premises which are supposed to derive from some source other than observation of the worlde. Kants argument was developed further by russells 1919. That phrase, popular and useful as it is, probably doesnt bear up very well under close logical scrutiny for it seems to imply that there is some argument that is the ontological argument, an argument of which the eleventhcentury argument, the. Several objections to the ontological argument for the existence of god. The dialogue below seeks to restore that simplicity, with one important modification. Pdf this paper presents the special issue on formal approaches to. Anselm defined god as a being than which no greater can be conceived, and which exists 2, and argued that this being must exist in the mind, even in the mind of the person who denies the existence of god. The form of the argument is that of a reductio ad absurdum argument. The ontological argument, an 11th century proof of the existence of god. This entry is a good place to start for clarification of the above notes to the argument. Many arguments fall under the category of the ontological, and they tend to involve arguments about the state of being or existing.
Immanuel kant put forward an influential criticism of the ontological argument in his critique of pure reason. Pdf a brief critical introduction to the ontological argument and. Kants criticisms of the ontological and ontotheological arguments for the existence of god. Make it clear that this is a response to the second objection. Frege s objection to the ontological argument 253 this question we will do well to consider the following extended passage from on the foundations of geometry. The ontological argument for the existence of god has enjoyed a. Anselm began with the concept of god as that than which nothing greater can be. Anselm, gaunilo, descartes, kant, hume, russell, aquinas, malcolm, plantinga. The ontological argument peter millican any argument which attempts to prove gods existence a priori based only on his nature can be termed an ontological argument. The objection needs to be that even if the skeletal argument can get us. Gaunilo raises the objection that just having the thought of something within your consciousness by. It is shaped by his central distinction between analytic and synthetic propositions.
According to this argument, there is no need to go out looking for physical evidence of gods existence. Hand out worksheet 2 and read through the passage as a class, clarifying points as you go. The relevance of kants objection to anselms ontological. An ontological argument is a philosophical argument for the existence of god that uses. Anselms argument together with gaunilos, aquinas and kants objections are conveniently summarized by kenneth einar himma in the internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Leibniz and the ontological argument rutgers university. Also, david hume offered an empirical objection, criticising its lack of. How does the ontological argument support the existence of god. A resources and revision website for a level religious studies, ocr, aqa and edexcel. Information for this video gathered from the stanford encyclopedia of. Ontological argument, argument that proceeds from the idea of god to the reality of god. Ppt the ontological argument powerpoint presentation. If in an identical judgement i reject the predicate and retain the subject, there arises a.
So, unlike guanilos objection, which attacks the form of the ontological argument, kants objection attacks the truth of one of the premises viz. This has proved a controversial claim, and efforts to evaluate it are complicated by the fact that the words existence is not a propertypredicate have been used by philosophers to make at least three different negative claims. Thus, a being that is omniscient lacks the ability to create free beings and is. Includes an interactive shell and a set of tool objects that mimic unix userland in an objectoriented way. The ontological argument powerpoint presentation free to download id. The ontological argument for the existence of god is a classical christian argument that contends that the very concept of god logically and necessarily demands existence. The mickey mouse guide to the ontological argument coauthored by gjw and mickey mouse wellington college department of philosophy and religion only the fool hath said in his heart that there is no god. The first ontological argument in the western christian tradition 1 was proposed by anselm of canterbury in his 1078 work proslogion.
A free powerpoint ppt presentation displayed as a flash slide show on id. Ontological argument objections flashcards quizlet. The ontological argument in anselms proslogion ii continues to generate a remarkable store of sophisticated commentary and criticism. Anselms a prioriargument for the existence of god today we will look at anselms ontological argument for the existence of god. Objections to the ontological argument there are various critiques and objections to the ontological argument. The most famous objection to the ontological argument is given in kant s dictum that existence is not a real predicate. Maydole ontological arguments are deductive arguments for the existence of god from general metaphysical principles and other assumptions about the nature or essence of god. His criticism is primarily directed at descartes, but also attacks leibniz. Kevin harrelson, kant s rejection of the ontological argument on epistemic grounds constitutes the most thorough criticism of that argument in the modern period harrelson, the ontological argument from descartes to hegel, 167.
1339 243 472 945 181 312 1004 1478 198 796 1110 1474 302 1369 800 364 680 240 62 945 171 332 874 360 21 1205 1261 783 251 174 605 881 173 163 1104 249